Culture and religion are not the same, though they are very close. They were talking about the appalling conditions women face in afghanistan, saudi arabia, nigeria, and other countries in which a more fundamentalist form of islam prevails long before september 11th and continue to do so. Whatever we define our success and our failure by becomes something that controls us and something we submit to. No feminist movement can relate to western feminism because of the way feminists formed their groups. Posted in class struggle, feminism and womens rights, how will communism work, marxismleninism, national liberation, revolutionary quotations, socialist revolution, the classics, theory, vladimir lenin. Feminism is frequently seen as a western import which is alien to islam and threatening to muslim values. Feminism is a secular ideology and islam today rests on fundamentalist foundations. This article argues that islamic feminism may appear to be the inevitable result of the convergence of islam and feminism yet it is also inadequate to concerns for sex equality in islam. The rise of global islamism in the form of alqaeda and the islamic state of iraq and alsham isis will pose a major challenge to the security of both western and muslimmajority nations for years to come. White western feminisms does not take into account the particular issues black women face at the intersection of both their blackness and their womanhood. Those who advocate that feminist projects be conducted within an islamic framework have clearly despaired of secular options for change without considering how have elaborated lilas argument against the possibility of the coexistence of islam and feminism because it explains the anxiety many. Islamic feminism and feminist theory abstract western feminist theory has developed significantly from its early roots in the suffrage movement. Dilemmas of islamic and secular feminists and feminisms. Throughout history she has been both a symbol of liberation and oppression, and yet she is.
But there are significant differences between islamic and western feminism. The islamic struggle against feminism it is not just a disagreement about how islamic law is to be interpreted or what sort of rights should be accorded to women. A free powerpoint ppt presentation displayed as a flash slide show on id. Her approach was firmly rooted in islam and was imbued with an antiimperialist essence which rejected the westernization of muslim societies. In theology, both reject the symbol of father for god. Roots, development and policies zaid eyadat the university of jordan abstract the current and future impact of islamic feminism within the political framework of the arab world is profound. One womans global journey fernea, elizabeth warnock on. Sources of the tradition before engaging in any meaningful discussion of feminism in islam, it is useful to refer to the sources of the islamic tradition, since much confusion surrounds the use of the term islam. Information and translations of feminism in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web. Lampooning islam and replicating western feminist ideas in muslim lands have served neither women nor feminism. Furthermore, the western idea of feminism takes god out of the picture and instead defines a womans worth, success and failure to that of a man. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. At the other end of the spectrum of islamic feminists stand female scholars of religion like asma barlas, who summarized her views under the succinct title of. If someone were to say that, then they are being misled.
Focusing on islamic feminism as a postcolonial framework for rights, islamic feminism is defined as the notion that women can work within their communities and towards islam to gain their rights. It fragmented, became exclusive rather than inclusive. Such women have a high degree of tolerance for domestic violence and oppression of. Ppt islamic feminism powerpoint presentation free to. Caste, gender, and feminism free ebook download as powerpoint presentation. Clash of religion and cultures mohammad iqbal research scholar phd department of social work maulana azad national urdu university hyderabad islamic feminism and parallelism of sex in islam islamic feminism is a feminist discourse that propagates gender equality and social justice within a prestructured islamic framework, in an attempt to achieve normative reconciliation between islam and womens rights. In saudi arabia, for example, feminism is deemed a. Feminist history of philosophy conference is one of the leading research topics in the international research conference domain.
Islamic feminism is the first theologydriven feminist discourse to have been broadly received by ordinary and privileged women alike. The author suggests that the rise of a new feminism rooted in islamic discourse, nonconfrontational, privatized and personalized, whose objective is to empower women within islam is not a post911 development but rather a result of unresolved. It places the west on a pedestal of gender empowerment, and thus ignores the systemic misogyny of western nations. Western feminism, analyzing and conceptualizing conflict, thesis for the degree of master of science, international studies, central connecticut state university, may 2003, chapter nine conclusion, p 7082. Full text of encyclopaedia of women and islamic cultures. Prior research on fundamentalist religious movements has focused attention on the complicated relationship between gender, family and religion. Philosophy and religion international relations political science civilization, western influence developing countries laws, regulations and rules social aspects feminists political activity intercultural. Aug 04, 2018 feminism is not the belief that women should be treated the same as men.
The good society is supported by the fundamental values of freedom, justice and solidarity. It is in such debates that islamic feminists, rather than relying on tradition or a proliferated feminism such as a specifically western feminism insist on a return to the quran and employ. This is how the western idea of feminism conflicts with. Islamic feminism should be evaluated pragmatically on grounds of strategic successes and failures, rather than rejecting or endorsing it wholesale. Islam, and only islam, was proposed to have the interest of muslim iranian women at heart.
This is the kind of feminism that centers white narratives and strips away the agency of women of color. The american society for the defense of tradition, family, and propertytfp spring. Her charisma and enormous popularity suggest that she can merge these two divergent strands of feminism. Western feminism is grounded in western values, thought, and ideology and those values differ from those of islam and arab tradition. Although islam and feminism are not completely without common ground, the values and principles of islam and feminism are generally contrary. Feminism is also a pervasive movement at protestant university. It has gained little traction in the western media that often confuses islam with cultural and tribal oppression of women.
Islam vs feminism contemporary topics of islamic thought. For last few decades, indian culture has been influenced by the western culture, and they are adopting the merits of the western culture like cleanliness, equal rights for both men and women, frankness, etc. Jul 04, 2018 in urdu free download free ebooks online urdu books pdf download urdu novels islamic download pleasure pdf. Understand islamic feminist practices within the context of the transnational feminist movement against capitalismglobalization. Muslim women focuses disproportionately on the middle east and north africa region. Mar 25, 2019 in 1821, clinton female seminary opened. Sikhism condemns blind rituals such as fasting, visiting places of pilgrimage, superstitions, worship of the dead, idol worship etc. Others feel african feminism became necessary in part due to white western feminism s exclusion of the experiences of the black woman and the continental african woman. Islamic system, others import them and use them as such, sometimes even from a secular perspective. An islamic sarsour style of feminism has to be shariacompliant in the if you cant beat em, join em mode. Bridget, a female member of ocf, would not say she rejects the equality of the sexes. Islamic feminism has elicited strong responses ranging from outright dismissal to enthusiastic approval from sections of the traditional religious establishment as well as some secular feminists. Secular feminists, however, rule out any possible compatibility between feminism and islam. Western style feminism, by any name it is called, is a secular order that seeks to wipe out my spirituality and force me to selfishly overemphasize women to the detriment of others.
Muslim and hindu womens public and private behaviors. In this new conjuncture, women from within islam and islamist movements in farflung places around the worldfrom malaysia, to morocco, to iran, and to the united statesbegan to articulate a holistic, gendersensitive construction of citizenship within the framework of an islamic modernity. I started the ball rolling to show good faith by taking out islamic feminism, and merging it with its leaf. One important feature of islamophobia is to caricature islam as misogynistic and oppressive to women and thus to advance imperialist hegemony. Although rooted in islam, the movements pioneers have also utilized secular, western, or otherwise nonmuslim feminist discourses, and have recognized the role of islamic feminism as part of an integrated global feminist movement. Sep 09, 2015 where the foothills of mount kenya merge into the desert, the people of samburu have maintained a strict patriarchy for over 500 years in northern kenya. In order to understand the current relevance of islamic feminism, this article. Project muse islam, feminism, and islamic feminism. Pdf in a phenomenological study with 16 american and french arab muslim women attending college in the united states and france, all selfdeclared as. Following this the king formed a commission to reform the code after which, in 2004, significant reforms were made. Dilemmas of islamic and secular feminists and feminisms1 by huma ahmedghosh2 abstract this paper explores ways in which a multifaceted understanding of islamic feminism can contribute to productive dialogue about the future of muslim women in both islamic and secular states. Beechers sister, writer harriet beecher stowe, was a student at hartford female seminary and later a teacher there. The quraan does not discriminate between man and woman when it comes to rewards and punishments, and only differentiates the two.
Mainstream feminism with its strong links to secularism and western values, has a tendency to perceive islam as inherently misogynist. Young arab muslim womens agency challenging western feminism. Improve the basic skills of critical thinking, analysis, and effective writing. Feminism ids bulletin volume 42 number 1 january 2011 beyond islam vs. I have my own movement that is in line with my islamic beliefs and values. Since the university is fairly liberal amongst christian colleges, femini sm is mostly a mainstream, supported cause. The reality and future of islamic feminism afghanistan. Western feminism why i disagree with some aspects of modern feminism. Islamophobia, feminism, feminists in muslim societies, gender. Yet the developments of postrevolutionary iran have made it difficult even for the most ardent believers of islam to completely sever ties with western feminism. Sikhism preaches that people of different races, religions, or sex are all equal in the eyes of god. There are various theories that suggest a model of relationship between them. The arabic press conflates islamic feminism with the secular womens movement. Islamic feminism is based on certain nonnegotiable values, i.
Doing business in the middle east the complete guide istizada. The reason islamic feminism has been perverted is because over centuries it had to conform to islamic law, sharia, which regulates to a faretheewell all behavior of women, men and children. Hatred of men, and masculinity, in western european nations, is open and oppressive to men. As it grew to encompass those women who were not white and middle class it was caught in the trap that ensnares most social movements. Jul, 2017 an islamic sarsour style of feminism has to be shariacompliant in the if you cant beat em, join em mode. Orthodox christians, in her explanation, are not disrespectful towards women. One of them tries to see religion as the soul of culture. Feminism is the liberation of women and girls all over the world from the patriarchy and misogyny that continues to harm and oppress them as a class of people. Perhaps no other social movement has wrought such profound changes in social morals and attitudes. Difference between indian culture and western culture with.
Introduction in the nonwest, feminism has largely been considered an alien concept, contrary to indigenous norms and traditions. Paired with the historical gains of islamic feminisms from the daughters of hajars islamic bill of rights for women in mosques. It is useful to note that while the gregorian calendar is the official norm in most of the middle east with saudi arabia as the exception, the islamic lunar calendar does also influence life in terms of religious festivals and events. If, generally speaking, feminism engages us in the world, motherhood, at least temporarily, draws us away. Muslimat, singular muslima vary widely between and within different societies. Without contesting the value of feminist thought in the struggles of muslim women, this essay critiques the easy conflation or inflation of the convergence of islam and feminism as islamic. At the same time, their adherence to islam is a shared factor that affects their lives to a varying degree and gives them a common identity that may serve to bridge the wide cultural, social, and economic differences between them.
This article argues that there has been a significant turn in the discourse of feminist politics in the islamic republic of pakistan. At the same time, many have fought these incursions on the basis of the. This view doesnt consider the fact that there could also be nonreligious cultures. Islamic feminism is related to the return to religion that many muslim societies have experienced in recent decades. Yet in the arab world and beyond many different groups and individuals as scholars, as charity and welfare providers, and as religious or political activists. Both insist that women may own their own property and dispose of it as they wish. Islamic feminism is defined by islamic scholars as being more radical than secular feminism, and as being anchored within the discourse of islam with the quran as its central text. An intersectional feminist against imperial feminism. Using data from a nationally representative survey of 30,000 hindu and muslim women, this study compares the. During recent times, the concept of islamic feminism has grown further with islamic groups looking to garner support from many aspects of society.
Islamic feminism explicates the idea of gender equality as part and parcel of the quranic notion of equality of all insan human beings and calls. Both indian culture and western culture are right at their places. Full text of encyclopaedia of women and islamic cultures, vol. In general, western feminism assumes the legitimacy of womanaswoman as it redefines western knowledge bases while validating womens constructive partaking. Whether living in the middle east or africa, in central asia, in pakistan, in southeast asia, or in europe and the americas, muslim women tend to. Introduction feminism has radically altered western culture in the latter half of the twentieth century. But just as modern sociopolitical models in the muslim world after the colonial period began, in the 20th century, to shift from western models of society and government to islamic models, feminism in the muslim world began to take on islamic forms rather than imitating the western feminist form. Feb 26, 2017 jazkallah khair for this post on the life and work of an amazing muslimah. A combination of islam and feminism has been advocated as a feminist discourse and practice articulated within an islamic paradigm by margot badran in. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext.
Magazine for years, and mainstream feminism is not awol on islam. Patriarchal rules of dress for women does not equal feminism. Islamic feminism critiques islamic patriarchy by historicizing and reinterpreting sources of scriptural authority. Islamic rather than familial or cultural can potentially enable them to recover their long obfuscated rights. Islam and feminism have contradictory views on the most fundamental issues in metaphysics, ethics, social and political philosophy and theology. This fact is essential to the different approaches that notify western white feminisms and the freedom struggles of women of color in general and african women scholars in particular. Although alghazali asserted that womens role within islam was rooted within the family structure and responsibilities of the home, alghazalis activism and involvement in the public sphere challenged the very gender roles she urged other women to abide. The social science scholarship most familiar to the west about. Not only are islamic feminists opening the doors of interpretation of sacred texts and debates on womens issues to groups other than muslims but they have also broken with the reactive gender conservatism and west phobia prevailing among fundamentalists, connected themselves with western feminism, and woven new connections between muslim women. Feminist history of philosophy is a conference track under the humanities and social science conference which aims to bring together leading academic scientists, researchers and research scholars to exchange and share their experiences and research results on all. Womens rights or feminism have been used to justify colonial policies and the invasion of muslim countries, both historically and also in recent times. Whereas western concepts of feminism are often resisted as foreign and subversive of muslim culture, arguments for womens equality from within islam hold a lot of potential for feminists.
Feminism is not the movement to make women equal to men in society. Islamic feminists advocate womens rights, gender equality, and social justice grounded in an islamic framework. By andrew berwick, london, 2011 pdf, 1518 pages, 7. The rise of cultural marxismmulticulturalism in western europe 2. Pdf on jan 1, 2010, beverly dawn metcalfe and others published reflecting on difference. Javier pereira bruno the university of texas at austin. Sexual revolution and liberation meant that sexual relations should be freed of the constraints associated with traditional christian virtue.
We need new ideas and concepts to ensure that the good society will. Feminism ziba mirhosseini abstract islamic feminism has gained currency since the 1990s and has become the label for a new brand of feminist scholarship and activism that is. Abstract the discussion in the current debate primarily explores the major areas in islamic discourses that are criticized by scholars and critics. The term islamic feminism began to be heard in the 1990s in various global locations. The compendium documents that the fear of islamisation is all but irrational. Many problems exist because of a resistance to cultural conversion. Between secular and islamic feminisms reflections on the middle east and beyond margot badran ir a. In social studies, a political ideology is a certain set of ethical ideals, principles, doctrines, myths or symbols of a social movement, institution, class or large group that explains how society should work and offers some political and cultural blueprint for a certain social order. What constitutes an islamic feminism, and where is it headed. Gender paradox academic criticism surrounds alghazalis paradoxical discourse in reference to the role of women. In the following article i will very briefly outline some of the main determinations of this complex contemporary phenomenon islamic feminisms. The status of the muslim woman in the middle east visavis the west continues to preoccupy scholars, feminists and human rights activists throughout the globe. Yet muslim women have been active in modern forms of feminism since the nineteenth century.
I will discuss the growth of the feminist or gender equality movements within the islamic community, and use a case study on egypt to provide a strong example of. Between inadequacy and inevitability fatima seedat. Islamic feminism and muslim womens rights activism in india. Maghazei explains that many of islamic feminists, inspired by edward said, believe that muslim women in the orientalist. Identify key issues in the western liberal feminism versus islamic feminism debate. Why the islamic colonisation and islamisation of western europe began. Two years later, catharine beecher founded the hartford female seminary, but the school did not survive beyond the 19 th century. Islamic feminism encounters western feminism 2 womens fundamental rights in public, familial, and personal domains have been undermined under the aegis of returning to ourselves and reviving an authentic national identity. Freedom comes with a certain responsibility in islamic whereas in the west freedom tends to degenerate into licentiousness, not in law but certainly in social and cultural. Such feminist tendencies rather give a bad name to the womens rights movement and fuel controversy, anger and resentment among muslims.
1080 1186 1619 851 171 1036 1228 1206 1310 1526 1645 1091 1374 1393 1466 1435 1535 1056 391 26 1072 970 33 1241 461 682 1224 149 257 1499 1309 904 343 134